Short answer: Many retirement calculators use Monte Carlo methods: they run a plan through a large number of forward-looking market paths and summarize how often the plan met the tool’s rule for “success.” That percentage is only as meaningful as the assumptions behind it. A Monte Carlo run is not the same thing as replaying a single recorded chronological market window. This page explains how to read those results. It does not document RetireGlide’s internal calculation engine.
What a Monte Carlo retirement run usually does
In plain terms, a Monte Carlo-style retirement calculator:
- Takes inputs (ages, balances, contributions, spending, asset mix, and often Social Security or pension assumptions).
- Builds many sequences of future returns (and often inflation). Some engines draw from a statistical model of asset-class behavior; others resample or bootstrap historical returns into new sequences. Both are stochastic sampling — they are not a one-for-one replay of a recorded market window in calendar order.
- Plays spending and contribution rules through each sequence.
- Reports the share of sequences that still funded the plan under the tool’s success definition — for example, ending with money left, or never hitting zero.
Schwab’s public methodology for its Retirement Income Calculator describes Monte Carlo projection of many hypothetical paths and a stated probability-of-success framing. T. Rowe Price’s educational PDF describes running on the order of 1,000 simulations and expressing results as a confidence-style score. Those documents describe those vendors’ tools. They are cited here as general methodology references, not as a description of RetireGlide.
Assumptions that move the percentage
Two tools can produce different “success” numbers on similar inputs when they differ on:
- Expected returns and volatility by asset class
- Whether paths come from a parametric model, historical resampling, or a hybrid
- Inflation treatment
- Taxes (flat haircut vs year-by-year)
- Social Security and required minimum distribution rules
- Whether spending is fixed or flexible
- How “failure” is defined (zero balance, unmet spending, etc.)
A percentage without those details is hard to interpret. Transparent tools publish the assumptions they use.
Monte Carlo simulations vs historical market paths
Keep these methods separate:
| Monte Carlo-style simulation | Historical path / chronological backtest | |
|---|---|---|
| Paths | Many sampled forward sequences (parametric draws, bootstrap/resampling of past returns, or hybrids) | Recorded markets replayed in calendar order (or fixed overlapping windows kept in historical sequence) |
| Strength | Can explore sequences that never occurred exactly as one past episode | Preserves real crash sequencing and past inflation episodes as they happened |
| Limit | Only as sound as the sampling model and assumptions | Limited sample of past regimes; past paths are not a promise of the future |
Bootstrapping historical returns into new orders is still Monte Carlo-style sampling. Replaying 1973–1982 (or another fixed window) in order is a historical backtest. They can complement each other in a planning process. They are not interchangeable labels for the same calculation. Past market performance does not predict future results.
How to read a success-style result
Hypothetical illustration — not a measurement from any named tool. A result such as “the plan succeeded in 800 of 1,000 simulated paths” would mean: under that tool’s model and rules, 800 paths still met the success definition. It does not mean there is a 20% personal chance of destitution, and it does not mean the other paths left the household with nothing in real life — many models assume rigid spending to the end.
Useful follow-up questions:
- If a path “fails,” when does stress show up?
- Would a modest spending change have altered the path?
- Which lever moves the result more: claiming age, savings rate, or asset mix?
- Does the tool show a spending range, not only a pass/fail rate?
See also sequence of returns risk and safe spending guardrails. For tool shopping context, see retirement calculators compared.
What a single percentage cannot answer alone
- Longevity: living longer than the modeled horizon changes the problem.
- Behavior: real households often trim spending; rigid simulations may overstate some risks and understate others.
- Taxes and health premiums: shallow tax models hide cliffs that show up in real returns.
- Goal definition: “never hit zero” is not the same as “maintain a lifestyle band.”
Use the percentage as one dashboard reading next to those questions — not as a verdict.
Before you decide: This guide is educational, not advice, and every example is hypothetical. See our disclaimer. Learn what a fiduciary advisor is.
You may want to talk with a fiduciary financial advisor about your situation.