How planning tools and advisors work

Retirement calculators compared: methods, costs and account linking

A side-by-side look at fixed-rate, Monte Carlo and historical-backtest retirement calculators, including ours, using the same criteria for each.

Updated 4 min readFact-checked

RetireGlide is our product; we include it alongside others using the same criteria.

Short answer: Retirement calculators fall into three types. Fixed-rate tools project one path from an assumed return. Monte Carlo tools run many simulated paths. Historical backtests replay past markets. The right type depends on your question: a quick check, a range of outcomes, or how a plan held up in real history.

How we compared

We looked at each tool's own public pages and noted the date we checked them. We compared the method, account linking and cost. We describe features only. We don't rate quality or security, or score any tool's results, and we don't pick a winner. Prices and features change, so check each provider's site.

Three kinds of calculator

TypeHow it worksGood for
Fixed-rateOne projection from set return and inflation ratesA quick first estimate
Monte CarloMany simulated market paths; reports how often the money lastedSeeing a range of outcomes
Historical backtestReplays actual past market sequencesSeeing how a plan held up in real history

Comparison table

ToolMethodAccount linkingCostSource (checked)
T. Rowe PriceMonte Carlo, 1,000 scenarios, Confidence ScoreNot requiredFreeT. Rowe Price (Oct 26, 2026)
Fidelity Retirement ScoreShort questionnaire (6 questions)Not requiredFreeFidelity (Oct 26, 2026)
EmpowerRetirement planner on a linked-account dashboardBuilt around linked accountsFree planner; paid advisory services offeredEmpower (Oct 26, 2026)
BoldinMonte Carlo and fixed projectionsLinking (PlannerPlus) or typingFree Basic; PlannerPlus $168/yrBoldin (Oct 26, 2026)
ProjectionLabMonte Carlo and historical backtestingNo direct linking; optional pluginsFree tier and paid plans; see ProjectionLab's pricing pageProjectionLab (Oct 26, 2026)
NerdWalletFixed-rate (defaults: 6%/5% returns, 3% inflation, plan to 95)Not requiredFreeNerdWallet (Oct 26, 2026)
FIRECalcHistorical backtestNot requiredFreeFIRECalc (Oct 26, 2026)
cFIREsimHistorical backtestNot requiredFreecFIREsim (Oct 26, 2026)
RetireGlideMonte Carlo, 1,000 market histories; historical backtesting on PremiumNo linking; typing, or screenshots you confirm (Premium)Free plan; Premium $59.99/yrRetireGlide pricing (Oct 26, 2026)

Tool summaries

  • T. Rowe Price: runs 1,000 Monte Carlo scenarios and shows a Confidence Score. Good fit if you want a free Monte Carlo view from a large fund company. Methodology (PDF).
  • Fidelity Retirement Score: six questions and a score. Good fit if you want a fast check.
  • Empower: a free planner built around linked accounts. Good fit if you want automatic tracking and are comfortable linking. See RetireGlide vs Empower.
  • Boldin: a detailed do-it-yourself planner. Good fit if you like hands-on modeling. See RetireGlide vs Boldin.
  • ProjectionLab: a modeling sandbox with Monte Carlo and backtesting. Good fit if you like building detailed models or plan outside the US. See RetireGlide vs ProjectionLab.
  • NerdWallet: a fixed-rate calculator with stated defaults. Good fit for a quick first number.
  • FIRECalc and cFIREsim: historical backtests popular with FIRE readers. Good fit if you want to see how a plan did across past markets.
  • RetireGlide: get started with a quick 3-minute voice interview, or switch to typing. No account linking, and a spending range tested against market histories. Good fit if you'd rather not share logins. Limits: US only, and screenshot import and the full tax engine are Premium features.

More one-to-one pages: MaxiFi, Fidelity, all comparisons.

Why results differ

Calculators disagree mostly because of assumptions: expected returns, inflation, planning age, taxes and how Social Security is modeled. A fixed 6% return and 1,000 simulated paths will rarely land on the same number.

Using more than one calculator

Some people run two tools with different methods and compare. If a Monte Carlo range and a historical backtest point the same way, that's a useful signal. If they don't, the gap usually comes from an assumption worth checking. Related: Monte Carlo simulation, planning without linking accounts, screenshots vs account linking. Try the free calculator.

Before you decide: This guide is educational, not advice, and every example is hypothetical. See the disclaimer and what a fiduciary advisor is.

You may want to talk with a fiduciary financial advisor about your situation.

Frequently asked questions

Which retirement calculator gives the right answer?

None can predict markets. Each one rests on assumptions about returns, inflation, taxes and lifespan, and the answer depends on those assumptions.

Are free retirement calculators reliable?

Many are useful for a first look. Check what they assume, such as a fixed return or a set planning age, and whether they model taxes and Social Security.

What is a Monte Carlo retirement calculator?

It runs a plan through many simulated market paths and reports how often the money lasted, instead of one projection from an average return.

Do I need to link my accounts?

No. Some tools are built around linked accounts. Others let you type balances or upload screenshots.

What is a historical backtest calculator?

It tests a plan against actual past market sequences. FIRECalc and cFIREsim work this way.

See this in your own plan

Try it with your own numbers. It's free and takes a few minutes.

Sources

What changed
  1. : Drafted for launch; awaiting RetireGlide Product review.