Spending and withdrawals

Retirement withdrawal-order strategies: which account comes first?

Compare taxable-first, tax-deferred-first, and proportional retirement withdrawals, with the IRS-required withdrawal first and Roth last in RetireGlide engine 1.6.0.

Updated 4 min readFact-checked

No single retirement withdrawal order fits every household. Taxable-first, tax-deferred-first, and proportional withdrawals recognize income and realize gains on different schedules, so a useful answer comes from comparing the same plan under each strategy after the IRS-required withdrawal is taken.

RetireGlide engine 1.6.0 models those three choices as educational scenarios. The withdrawal the IRS requires from tax-deferred accounts starting in your early 70s — age 73 or 75 by birth year (called an RMD) — is taken first, and Roth remains the last discretionary source in every version 1 strategy.

What does each withdrawal-order strategy mean?

Withdrawal order controls how a remaining cash shortfall is funded after income such as wages, pensions, Social Security, portfolio distributions, and the IRS-required withdrawal is counted. The strategy changes which account bears the discretionary draw; it does not switch off tax rules or that required withdrawal.

The three engine 1.6.0 choices are deliberately narrow so the comparison is understandable and reproducible. They do not include a Roth-first option.

  • Taxable-first: use taxable assets for the discretionary shortfall, then tax-deferred assets, then Roth if the first two sources are exhausted.
  • Tax-deferred-first: use traditional IRA and other pre-tax assets first, then taxable assets, then Roth.
  • Proportional: split the discretionary draw across taxable and tax-deferred balances in proportion to their current balances, with Roth used only after those sources are exhausted.

Why is the IRS-required withdrawal taken before the selected order?

The IRS-required withdrawal is a legal minimum, not an optional spending choice. Owners of traditional IRAs and many employer plans generally must begin annual distributions at the applicable age — 73 or 75 by birth year — and that amount is generally included in taxable income except for any previously taxed basis.

Engine 1.6.0 therefore removes the required amount from tax-deferred accounts before applying the selected discretionary order. If that required withdrawal and other income already cover spending and taxes, the selected strategy may have little or no discretionary withdrawal to allocate that year.

How can the three strategies produce different modeled paths?

Picture the same retired household with money in taxable, traditional, and Roth accounts. In a qualitative side-by-side comparison that holds everything else equal, a taxable-first run may realize gains while leaving more pre-tax money for later; a tax-deferred-first run may recognize more ordinary income earlier while reducing the balance exposed to future IRS-required withdrawals; a proportional run spreads those effects across both account types.

Nothing else in that comparison changes: spending, claiming ages, portfolio assumptions, and market-return sequence stay the same. The calculation engine recomputes taxes and the withdrawals needed to pay those taxes together, then reports each strategy's tax path, required-withdrawal path, Medicare costs, portfolio balances, and forecast outcomes. This example intentionally gives no numeric winner because no one strategy wins for every household and no specific engine result is being quoted here.

Why does Roth stay last in the version 1 strategies?

Qualified Roth withdrawals generally do not add taxable income, and Roth IRAs do not require lifetime IRS-required withdrawals for the original owner. Keeping Roth last isolates the choice between taxable and tax-deferred funding while preserving Roth as the final discretionary pool in all three comparisons.

That is an engine design boundary, not a claim that Roth always comes last. A future Roth-first or threshold-aware strategy would need to be explicitly designed, versioned, tested, and compared as a separate lever rather than implied by an AI explanation.

How to read a modeled comparison

Compare more than one output. Lifetime tax can move differently from Medicare premiums, ending assets, annual cash flow, or the size of future IRS-required withdrawals. A strategy that looks favorable on one measure can look less favorable on another, especially when Social Security taxation, capital gains, state tax, or higher Medicare premiums (called IRMAA) enter the path.

RetireGlide's versioned calculation engine performs every withdrawal, tax, projection, and simulation calculation. AI may propose a strategy input and explain the computed differences, but it never calculates or ranks the outcomes itself; the user confirms any plan input before it is saved.

Frequently asked questions

What is the default withdrawal order in RetireGlide?

Taxable-first is the default when no strategy is selected. The IRS-required withdrawal is still taken first, and Roth remains last for discretionary funding in all three engine 1.6.0 strategies.

Does proportional mean equal withdrawals from each account?

No. Engine 1.6.0 divides the discretionary draw between taxable and tax-deferred pools according to their current balances, so the split changes as those balances change.

Can a withdrawal order eliminate the IRS-required withdrawal?

No. The selected order applies only after required distributions. Earlier tax-deferred draws can reduce the balance used for later required-withdrawal calculations, but the order cannot waive an amount that is due.

Why can withdrawal order affect Medicare premiums?

Tax-deferred withdrawals and realized taxable gains can change modified adjusted gross income (the figure Medicare uses). Medicare generally uses income from two years earlier for higher premiums (called IRMAA), so different income timing can produce different premium paths.

See this in your own plan

Try it with your own numbers. It's free and takes a few minutes.

Sources

What changed
  1. : Published.