A Roth conversion moves money from a traditional IRA or 401(k) into a Roth IRA — you pay tax on the money now so it grows tax-free later. It makes sense when your tax rate today is lower than the rate you (or your heirs) would otherwise pay on that money — and the most common place that happens is the 'golden window' between retirement and the IRS-required withdrawal age, when wages have stopped but forced income hasn't started.
The bracket arbitrage
Every conversion is a bet on relative rates: tax paid at today's marginal rate versus tax avoided at tomorrow's. A retiree with big pre-tax balances often faces higher rates later — IRS-required withdrawals stack on Social Security, and a surviving spouse eventually files single, where the same income hits higher brackets. Converting enough each year to 'fill up' a low bracket (say, to the top of the 12% or 22% bracket) while rates are temporarily low is the classic pattern.
Conversions are also an estate play: heirs who inherit a traditional IRA must generally drain it within 10 years, often during their own peak earning years. Inheriting a Roth is dramatically kinder.
The costs people forget
Conversion income is real income in the year it lands, and it drags side effects with it:
- Higher Medicare premiums (called IRMAA) — conversion income two years ago sets this year's surcharge; a large conversion at 63+ can raise premiums at 65.
- ACA subsidies — for pre-65 retirees on marketplace coverage, conversion income reduces or eliminates premium credits; near a cliff, one extra dollar can cost thousands.
- Social Security taxation — conversions raise provisional income, pulling more of your benefit into taxable income in that year.
- Paying tax from the converted funds — using IRA dollars to pay the conversion tax shrinks the amount that reaches the Roth; conversions work better when the tax is paid from a taxable account.
The five-year rules, briefly
Each conversion has its own five-year clock for penalty-free access to the converted principal before age 59½. Separately, Roth earnings are tax-free once you're 59½ and any Roth IRA of yours has been open five years. After 59½, the per-conversion clocks stop mattering for penalties — but the five-year account rule still applies to earnings.
How to size a conversion
There's no universal right amount — the answer is a year-by-year comparison against brackets, higher Medicare-premium tiers, and your spending needs. This is a problem a test against 1,000 market histories handles well: model conversion schedules against your actual accounts and see lifetime taxes, required-withdrawal trajectories, and ending balances side by side before you act. Educational tools can show you the trade-offs; a large conversion decision is also worth a session with a tax professional.