Taxes, RMDs and Roth

Roth conversions in retirement: when they make sense (and when they don't)

Paying tax now to skip tax later only wins under specific conditions. The bracket arbitrage behind Roth conversions (pay tax on the money now so it grows tax-free later), the golden window between retirement and IRS-required withdrawals, and the costs people forget.

Updated 3 min readFact-checked

A Roth conversion moves money from a traditional IRA or 401(k) into a Roth IRA — you pay tax on the money now so it grows tax-free later. It makes sense when your tax rate today is lower than the rate you (or your heirs) would otherwise pay on that money — and the most common place that happens is the 'golden window' between retirement and the IRS-required withdrawal age, when wages have stopped but forced income hasn't started.

The bracket arbitrage

Every conversion is a bet on relative rates: tax paid at today's marginal rate versus tax avoided at tomorrow's. A retiree with big pre-tax balances often faces higher rates later — IRS-required withdrawals stack on Social Security, and a surviving spouse eventually files single, where the same income hits higher brackets. Converting enough each year to 'fill up' a low bracket (say, to the top of the 12% or 22% bracket) while rates are temporarily low is the classic pattern.

Conversions are also an estate play: heirs who inherit a traditional IRA must generally drain it within 10 years, often during their own peak earning years. Inheriting a Roth is dramatically kinder.

The costs people forget

Conversion income is real income in the year it lands, and it drags side effects with it:

  • Higher Medicare premiums (called IRMAA) — conversion income two years ago sets this year's surcharge; a large conversion at 63+ can raise premiums at 65.
  • ACA subsidies — for pre-65 retirees on marketplace coverage, conversion income reduces or eliminates premium credits; near a cliff, one extra dollar can cost thousands.
  • Social Security taxation — conversions raise provisional income, pulling more of your benefit into taxable income in that year.
  • Paying tax from the converted funds — using IRA dollars to pay the conversion tax shrinks the amount that reaches the Roth; conversions work better when the tax is paid from a taxable account.

The five-year rules, briefly

Each conversion has its own five-year clock for penalty-free access to the converted principal before age 59½. Separately, Roth earnings are tax-free once you're 59½ and any Roth IRA of yours has been open five years. After 59½, the per-conversion clocks stop mattering for penalties — but the five-year account rule still applies to earnings.

How to size a conversion

There's no universal right amount — the answer is a year-by-year comparison against brackets, higher Medicare-premium tiers, and your spending needs. This is a problem a test against 1,000 market histories handles well: model conversion schedules against your actual accounts and see lifetime taxes, required-withdrawal trajectories, and ending balances side by side before you act. Educational tools can show you the trade-offs; a large conversion decision is also worth a session with a tax professional.

Frequently asked questions

What age makes sense for Roth conversions?

The highest-value years are typically between retirement and the IRS-required withdrawal age (and before Social Security starts) — income is low, so conversions fill cheap brackets. Converting after those required withdrawals begin is harder: they must come out first and can't themselves be converted.

Do Roth conversions count against higher Medicare premiums?

Yes. Those premiums (called IRMAA) are based on your modified AGI from two years prior, and conversion income counts. Retirees near Medicare age often cap conversions just below a premium threshold.

Is there a limit on how much I can convert?

No dollar limit — you can convert any amount in any year. The practical limit is the tax bill: each dollar converted is ordinary income, so large conversions climb through brackets quickly.

Can I undo a Roth conversion?

No. Recharacterization of conversions was eliminated in 2018 — conversions are permanent, which is another reason to model before converting.

See this in your own plan

Try it with your own numbers. It's free and takes a few minutes.

Sources

What changed
  1. : Published.