Taxes, RMDs and Roth

Roth conversion ladder: five-year rules and early withdrawals

Roth conversion ladders: conversion-year income tax, per-conversion five-year clocks for the 10% additional tax, withdrawal ordering, and bridge years.

Updated 5 min readFact-checked

Short answer: A Roth conversion ladder is a series of yearly conversions from a traditional IRA (or similar pre-tax dollars) into a Roth IRA. The taxable part of each conversion is usually ordinary income in the conversion year. Separately, each conversion has its own five-year period that can matter for the 10% additional tax if converted dollars are withdrawn early while under 59½ — generally on the taxable portion of the converted amount withdrawn within that period. Earnings inside the Roth follow different qualified-distribution rules. This page is educational, not tax advice.

How a conversion ladder works

  1. Move a chosen dollar amount from a traditional IRA (or other eligible pre-tax balance) into a Roth IRA. That step is the conversion.
  2. Report the taxable part of the conversion as ordinary income for that tax year (see IRS Publication 590-B).
  3. Wait out that conversion’s five-year period before taking those converted dollars if the goal is to stay clear of the conversion-related 10% additional tax while under 59½ (unless another IRS exception applies).
  4. Repeat in later years so later “rungs” mature in sequence.
  5. After 59½, the 10% additional tax on early distributions generally no longer applies the same way; earnings still need a qualified distribution to come out tax-free.

Related reading: Roth conversions explained, how much to convert to Roth each year.

Two different five-year clocks

Confusing these two rules is a common ladder failure mode.

1) Per-conversion clock (10% additional tax risk)

IRS rules give converted amounts their own five-year periods for purposes of the early-distribution 10% additional tax. If converted dollars are withdrawn before that period ends, while under 59½, the 10% additional tax generally applies to the taxable portion of the converted amount attributable to that withdrawal within the period — not automatically to every nontaxable dollar tied to the conversion — unless another exception applies. Income tax on the conversion itself was already handled in the conversion year for the taxable part.

Fidelity’s Jan 9, 2026 page (“What to know about the Roth IRA 5-year aging rule”) states that the 5-year rule is counted separately for each conversion, and that a conversion anytime in 2026 starts that conversion’s clock in January 2026 (a 2027 conversion cannot be attributed to 2026). Primary detail for tax treatment of early withdrawals of converted amounts remains Publication 590-B and Topic 557.

2) Earnings / qualified-distribution clock

Roth earnings generally come out tax-free only in a qualified distribution. That usually requires a five-year aging period measured from the beginning of the tax year of your first contribution (or conversion) to any Roth IRA, plus age 59½ or another qualifying reason (disability, death, or limited first-home amounts, among others). Fidelity’s same page summarizes the earnings aging rule in those terms. That earnings clock is not the same as each conversion’s early-withdrawal clock.

How Roth IRA money comes out (ordering)

For nonqualified distributions, IRS ordering rules matter. In broad terms, money leaves a Roth IRA in this order:

  1. Regular Roth contributions
  2. Conversion and rollover amounts (oldest first; within a conversion, taxable portion before nontaxable)
  3. Earnings last

That ordering is why a ladder can work: seasoned conversion amounts are reached before earnings. See Publication 590-B for the official ordering rules.

Educational rung example (hypothetical)

Hypothetical only — not a recommendation.

Alex stops W-2 work at age 50 and wants about $40,000 a year from conversions starting at 55.

Tax yearActionEarliest year that conversion’s five-year period ends (illustrative)*
2026Convert $40,0002031
2027Convert $40,0002032
2028Convert $40,0002033
2029Convert $40,0002034
2030Convert $40,0002035
2031Withdraw from the 2026 conversion amount (if still under 59½, after that conversion’s period) and optionally convert another rung—

*Illustrative timing that treats each conversion’s five-year period as counted from the start of its tax year, consistent with common IRS and Fidelity explanations of conversion-year timing. Individual Form 8606 reporting and plan records determine the actual year.

From 2026 through 2030, Alex still needs a bridge for living costs that does not depend on pulling those new conversion rungs early.

Bridge years: what funds the wait

Without roughly five years of other resources, a ladder is incomplete. Households often use:

  • Taxable brokerage cash or sales (capital gains rules differ from IRA early-distribution rules)
  • Roth contribution basis (ordering rules allow contributions first)
  • Part-time or other income

Bridge design also interacts with Marketplace health subsidies: conversion income raises MAGI in the conversion year. See the ACA subsidy cliff in early retirement.

Where ladders break down

  • Starting conversions without a bridge, then withdrawing converted dollars before each clock ends
  • Treating “tax paid at conversion” as “later withdrawals are free of every tax” — income tax at conversion and the later 10% additional tax are different
  • Mixing up earnings rules with conversion clocks
  • Assuming you can convert only after-tax IRA dollars: if you have both pre-tax and after-tax (basis) money in traditional, SEP or SIMPLE IRAs, the taxable share of a conversion is figured pro rata across all of those IRAs combined, using year-end balances on Form 8606
  • One oversized conversion year that pushes ordinary income into higher brackets and, for some households, higher health-premium costs

A 72(t) / SEPP schedule is a different IRS path: payments can begin earlier, with stricter ongoing rules. Compare both against accounts and tax years — educational comparison only.

For age-55 employer-plan access instead of IRA conversions, see the rule of 55 and retiring at 55: what changes.

Before you decide: This guide is educational, not advice, and every example is hypothetical. See our disclaimer. Learn what a fiduciary advisor is.

You may want to talk with a fiduciary financial advisor about your situation.

Frequently asked questions

Do I owe the 10% additional tax when I convert?

No. A conversion is not treated as an early distribution for that 10% tax. The taxable part of the conversion is generally ordinary income for the conversion year. Later, if converted amounts are withdrawn before that conversion’s five-year period ends and you are under 59½, the 10% additional tax generally applies to the taxable portion of those converted dollars withdrawn within the period, unless another IRS exception applies.

What is the difference between the two five-year rules?

One clock is for each conversion (and similar rollover amounts): it can matter for the 10% additional tax when those converted dollars come out early. A separate five-year aging rule applies to whether earnings come out tax-free in a qualified distribution. Earnings also generally need age 59½ (or another qualifying reason) for a qualified distribution.

What do people live on while the first rungs mature?

Common bridge sources are taxable brokerage cash, original Roth IRA contributions (which can come out without income tax or the 10% additional tax), and other non-retirement income. Without a bridge, some households end up taking converted dollars before their five-year clocks end.

How does a Roth ladder compare with a 72(t) schedule?

They address early access differently. A ladder waits for each conversion’s five-year period before those converted dollars are free of the conversion-related 10% risk; a 72(t) / SEPP schedule can start sooner but must follow IRS payment rules for the required period. Breaking a 72(t) schedule can bring back the 10% tax for prior years, plus interest, under IRS rules.

If I convert in December, when does that conversion’s five-year clock start?

For the conversion five-year period, the clock is tied to the tax year of the conversion. A conversion completed anytime in a calendar year is generally treated as starting that year’s clock on January 1 of that year (Fidelity’s Jan 9, 2026 explainer states the same for a 2026 conversion; IRS Publication 590-B is the primary reference).

See this in your own plan

Try it with your own numbers. It's free and takes a few minutes.

Sources

What changed
  1. : Content revision: SEO/accuracy pass (Aaron-approved 2026-11-05).
  2. : Published.