Short answer: The 4% rule withdraws a fixed, inflation-adjusted dollar amount each year. That gives a steady paycheck, but the portfolio can run down after bad markets. Variable percentage withdrawal (VPW) takes a changing percentage of what's left, so it adapts to markets. The trade-off is income that rises and falls with the portfolio.
Constant-dollar: the 4% rule
The 4% rule traces to William Bengen's 1994 research, as the FPA Journal (Oct 2015) describes. Withdraw 4% of the portfolio in year one, then raise that dollar amount with inflation each year, whatever markets do.
Where it breaks: the withdrawal never responds to markets. A run of poor returns early in retirement can shrink the portfolio while withdrawals keep rising. See sequence-of-returns risk.
Constant-percentage
Withdraw the same percentage of the current balance every year. If the portfolio falls 20%, income falls 20%. It adapts fully, but the percentage doesn't change as the horizon shortens.
Variable percentage withdrawal
How the VPW table works
VPW uses a table by age and stock/bond mix, published by the Bogleheads community. Each year you look up your percentage and multiply it by your current balance. The percentage rises with age.
Illustrative example: Say your table percentage at 65 is 4.8% (example only). On a hypothetical $1,000,000 portfolio, that's $48,000 for the year. If the portfolio is $900,000 the next year and the percentage at 66 is 4.9% (example only), that's $44,100.
Couples use the younger spouse's age
Using the younger age stretches the horizon and lowers the starting percentage.
The trade-off: income swings
Because VPW withdraws a percentage of what's left, it's designed not to empty the portfolio before the end of the period you pick. That works because withdrawals shrink as the portfolio shrinks. After a steep market drop, VPW income can fall sharply too. Many households pair it with a floor of steady income.
Guardrails
Guardrails sit between the two: spending stays steady until the withdrawal rate drifts past a set limit, then adjusts. See safe-spending guardrails.
Comparison
| Method | Income stability | Spending level | Legacy | Depletion risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Constant-dollar (4% rule) | High | Fixed at the start | Varies widely | Higher after poor early markets |
| Constant-percentage | Low | Moves with markets | Tends to remain | Low; income falls instead |
| VPW | Low to medium | Rises with age | Planned to near zero at the end | Low within the period; income falls instead |
| Guardrails | Medium | Adjusts at limits | Varies | Lower than constant-dollar, with cuts at limits |
Pairing a method with an income floor
Social Security, pensions or annuity income can cover essentials, so the variable method only affects discretionary spending. See withdrawal order.
Seeing the trade-off in a forecast
Illustrative: the free RetireGlide calculator shows how often the money lasted across 1,000 market histories, plus a spending range. A wide range shows a plan that's more sensitive to markets. See also Monte Carlo simulation and safe withdrawal rates.
Before you decide: This guide is educational, not advice, and every example is hypothetical. See the disclaimer and what a fiduciary advisor is.
You may want to talk with a fiduciary financial advisor about your situation.